Churchill, World War 2 and Brexit

First the Maisky Diaries and now Kevin Myers (PM Boris Johnson is too high a price to pay for Ukexit, Sunday Times, 17th April 2016). Churchill’s reputation was always going to come under scrutiny at some point but, typically, the scrutiny is not coming from orthodox British historians. Myers is wrong about the British public not liking Churchill. They had good reason to dislike him but his absolute determination not to make a deal with Hitler in 1940 was the basis of his popularity ever afterwards. Indeed, had it not been for the British public (particularly Labour supporters) he would probably have lost office by 1943 (not least because his penchant for military disasters in WW1 continued in WW2) and replaced by Halifax, Cripps, Eden (an utter weakling as Myers says) or Lloyd George (the only one of the four who wasn’t a weakling), who would have done a deal with Hitler but regretted it afterwards. As his funeral cortege was going down the Thames in 1965, dockers, many of them war veterans, I suspect, lowered their cranes in salute. (Some upper class woman told Maisky that Churchill, whose mother was from the southern states of the US, had negroid features. I think that is worse than saying he was Irish!)
 
Myers’ comments about Churchill’s blood lust against German cities (which are absolutely spot on) raise an interesting issue. There is at least one programme per day (usually many more) about WW2 on at least one of the many British channels I have. Apart from the fact that the programmes are a total bore, they must be getting up the noses of the Germans big time at this stage. If the British vote for Brexit, the nonsense about job losses will be disappear off the papers immediately but what the media forget (both here and in Britain) is that the Germans are going to use Brexit as an opportunity to express their frustration at the wall-to-wall programmes on British TV channels about WW2. They are likely to anyway – you can imagine a state visit to London by the German President where he politely but firmly calls time on these boring programmes – but Brexit will be seen by the Germans as an opportunity to demand an end to WW2ism by the British. And they will be typically Germanic in how they demand it, i.e. not diplomatic. Something to look forward to.

 

Geldof and Willy

I was up Benbulben last week. The locals aren’t friendly so we had to go up a very tough way. Great views from the top. If Yeats (or Willy, as his intimate friend Geldof calls him) had ever got up there his poetry would really have taken off ....

Geldof is a good programme maker but why does he have to be so foulmouthed? It took away considerably from what was otherwise a very fine programme. In the midst of the wall-to-wall crass and embarrassing programmes on all channels and articles in all newspapers it was interesting, entertaining, informative and important but Geldof had to reduce it to the level of a pub discussion with his crude language.

Why does RTE not realize that a television programme is not the same as a discussion in a pub? No wonder this society is in the gutter.

Mortgage Lending Rules

The ESRI says that the Central Bank's mortgage lending rules should be modified to ensure more housing is built. As it happens, they should be modified (but not just yet). The recently retired Governor of the Central Bank probably knew that they would be so possibly opted to make them stiffer than they should be. Changing the rules won't increase supply (certainly not in the short term) but will increase demand. It makes more sense to keep supply and demand as close to equal as possible pending the election of a new government that can get to grips with the housing mess. The current rules are dampening demand at a time when supply is inadequate. That makes sense. (Hopefully, the new Government will opt not to use good land for housing but to go for greater population density, the development of brown sights, etc.)

The debate about mortgage rules should not just be a technical one. Indeed, the technical debate should follow a wider cultural debate about the role of property in society. The technical details are important but the real problem is cultural: how to wean people off thinking about property as a money-making machine. The property industry obviously should be profitable but it is neither necessary nor appropriate for the majority of the population to be players in the industry. Buying a house is the most important asset most people buy but most people buy a house to live in, raise their families in and leave to their descendants. They don't get into the property market for business reasons, except that during the Celtic Tiger many did. The results were predictable.

It is much harder to change cultural practices than laws. Irish society seems to believe that property is a ticket to easy riches. Riches aren't picked up easily anywhere by anyone (other than lottery winners although we should always remember that the famous French PM, Tiger Clemenceau, described lotteries as a tax on idiots). Irish society discovered in 2008 that the property market can be as difficult to negotiate as any other market. I get the impression, however, that the lessons of 2008 are being forgotten and that the love affair with property is on again.

Attempts by the Minister for Finance to put pressure on the Central Bank about mortgage lending rules before the general election were typical of how populist political parties behave. They love to run with the hares and hunt with the hounds, talk out of both sides of their mouths at the same time and generally behave like yahoos. That is what has to change. The President (as someone who can talk about cultural issues) and, more pointedly, the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance and all other Ministers should address the cultural problem. They need to start the process of weaning this society off the notion that the property market is a mechanism for easy riches. It took perhaps a generation to get (most) people to understand that drinking and driving wasn't on. We still have problems with drinking and driving but far less than we once had. So, we can expect it to take at least a generation to educate people into treating the purchase of property in the right way, to tackle the problem of greed that is at the heart of the love affair with property and to leave the money-making aspect of the industry to the professionals.






1916 is all about 2016

The 1916 carry-on is all about 2016 really. It is an attempt to disguise things like partition, the refusal to back the Provisional IRA in the North after 1969 (they were exactly the same type of people as Pearse and co) and the surrender of sovereignty to the EU. As the PSNI begins a murder investigation into the death of a prison officer, it is just as well that the Irish State choose to pretend there was a difference between 1916 and 1969 (despite doing a great deal to light the fuse there with the 50th anniversary celebrations in 1966). The continued threat from dissident Republicans reflects the fact that not everyone in the North is prepared to pretend that 1916 and 1969 were different. Most people in the Republic don't realize (not least because the Republic is almost as as partitionist as Northern Ireland) that for Northern Nationalists the Treaty of 1921 meant nothing. Their situation didn't improve. Indeed, it worsened for another fifty years although the creation of the British welfare state after WW2 gave Nationalists some breaks that some took and that enabled a new generation of Nationalist leaders to emerge in the 1960s.
 
The 1916 Rising provided a leadership cadre that prevented conscription being extended to Ireland in 1918, kept the Irish State out of World War 2 and prevented conscription being extended to the North during WW2. The 1916 Rising, therefore, prevented far greater bloodshed in WW1 and the possible destruction of Irish society, North and South, in WW2. Eamon De Valera objected to conscription being extended to the North. Churchill’s generals told Churchill to let it go as they were satisfied they would get more volunteers from the 32 counties than conscripted soldiers from the North only. Dev would have sought to prevent people from here joining the British forces had conscription being extended to the North and he would probably have broadly succeeded. Those are considerable achievements that Home Rule and John Redmond would never have achieved.
 
The 1916 Rising, though necessary, was violent and bloody (as all wars are) and should not be celebrated like a carnival. Commemorated, yes, jumped on by bandwagoning politicians trying to disguise their many failures and betrayals, no. The contrast between the celebrations (they will now look - what they are - uncouth after the murder of the Northern prison officer), on the one hand, and the condition of this state, on the other, is embarrassing. Much of the torrent of print and broadcast media output about 1916 is irrelevant and clearly related to the agendas of today. About those, perhaps the less said the better.


 


Politics as a business

Power (to the extent that Irish Governments still have any) is collapsing. Most TDs don’t want it. They all want office (which includes being a TD/Senator and doesn’t have to involve being a Minister). Being a successful politician today is not about changing things, delivering a new vision or anything of that kind. Eamon de Valera had the best part of a century to deliver the vision he had for Ireland – an extraordinary privilege. A pity Michael Collins didn’t get the same time.

Today’s politicians are entrepreneurs. Politics is a business like any other. It has its risks and its rewards. The rewards are not the salary and pension of a TD or senator (though they are not to be sneezed at) but the doors that are opened to celebrity status, board membership, EU perks, joining the rest of the elite who are richer than politicians, etc., etc.  That has been the pattern in Britain since, probably, the late 19th century. Before that, most politicians were grandees or gentry of one kind or another. Since, give, or take, the early 20th century a great many people who went into politics in Britain as commoners ended up with peerages. They wanted to join the upper class. Today, politics globally is a vehicle for the same kind of advancement, and for little else. [Reading The Maiskey Diaries bears this out. At least 50% of the footnotes refer to British politicians, who, the footnotes state, ended up getting peerages as in “Joe Smth MP, the first Baron this”, or “Undersecretary Jones, the first Viscount that”.]

Many of the smaller parties and independents in the 32nd Dail haven’t the slightest interest in behaving responsibly, which involves taking power and wielding it with discipline, which, in turn, involves a whip system for certain measures that must go through the Dail. It also involves compromises, including moral compromises. The principal planks in a government’s programme, if endorsed by its parliamentary party(ies), should be delivered in a disciplined manner. However, Government programmes should be short. They should be of the order of “we will do the best we can” rather than sixty pages of promises that are then delivered in a box ticking operation without regard to whether they should be delivered or not. Matters of conscience and strictly parliamentary business should of course not be whipped.

It is possible that we are inching towards a greater understanding of the need to separate the rights of TDs as members of parliament from their obligation to support a government programme to which they are committed (Kenny might have lost fewer TDs if he had given his party a free vote on the suicide abortion Bill). So, one step forward. However, it is very much a case of two back as it is obvious that other than FF and FG no one wants to be in government. That might sound contradictory but if you think about it, it isn’t. Many of the smaller parties and independents would have zero credibility if they supported a government or, God forbid, joined one. They are so extreme (in the sense of not being willing to recognize the harsh realities of life) that any derogation from the absolute positions they adopt (100% increase in government spending and the abolition of all taxes except for taxes on the “wealthy” – who dey Gay?) would cause them to lose their seats and be replaced by other headbangers. Their business model is built on adopting positions from which there can be no retreat and no compromise. They created that business model (or rather than fact that the Dail has 100 TDs too many created it) and they know they will live or die by it.

So, we are left with FF and FG to form a government. They clearly can’t, not this side of a May election but possibly after a May election, particularly as FF will win more seats than FG and will claim the Taoiseach’s office. It is critical, therefore, for FF that they are not blamed for causing a May election. All of their jockeying for position is aimed at not being blamed for the next election. I don’t know if FG has realized that.

An interesting final point: what happens to the Senate election if the Dail is dissolved before the new Senate election is completed? No one seems to know.

First Three, Four or Five, Respectively, Past The Post System

We pride ourselves on the fact that we don't have a first-past-the-post electoral system but, in reality, we do or a variation of it. In most three seat constituencies the candidates in the first three positions at the end of the first count in the 2011 general election were elected, with the same thing happening to the first four and five candidates in the four and five seat constituencies, respectively.

The candidates in the first three places at the end of the first count were elected in 15 of the 17 three seat constituencies. They were not all elected on the first count or in in the order in which they appeared at the end of the first count. In Dublin North East, two candidates (SF and FF) were ahead of the third candidate (the second successful Labour candidate) at the end of the first count but failed to be elected. Both candidates presumably failed to attract transfers, which is typical of SF candidates and was to be expected of FF candidates in 2011.

In 9 of the 15 four seat constituencies, the candidates in the first four places at the end of the first count were elected, again not all on the first count or in the order in which they appeared at the end of the first count. In the five of the remaining six constituencies, three of the first four candidates at the end of the first count were elected while two of the first four candidates at the end of the first count were elected in one constituency.

In 8 of the 11 five seat constituencies, the candidates in the first five places at the end of the first count were elected (again not all on the first count, etc.). In the other three constituencies, four of the first five placed candidates at the end of the first count were elected.

In most constituencies, a candidate who was in the first three, four or five positions (as appropriate) at the end of the first count but failed to be elected was beaten by a candidate who was not far behind him/her at the end of the first count (frequently five hundred votes or less). Only in Galway East where four candidates (two FG and two independents) were ahead of the final candidate to be elected (Labour) at the end of the first count was the result unusual.

The results have considerable significance for Labour, which like the Liberal Democrats in Britain last year, don't appear to realize they are going to be annihilated. Paddy Ashdown, a former leader of the Lib Dems, said he would eat his hat if the Lib Dems did badly but David Steel, a former Liberal leader, got it right the next day when he said that the Lib Dems lost 49 (I think) of their 57 seats not because of what they had done in government but because of the promises they broke to get into government. I expected the Lib Dems to be wiped out and I expect Labour to be down to between 0-10 seats after our election for the same reason that the Lib Dems were punished.

Unlike large parties, which have large numbers elected locally and nationally (thereby allowing those parties to remain in touch with the electorate), smaller parties quickly lose touch with their bases and their promises. They lose the run of themselves and become arrogant. Small parties suffer in coalition not because they are small but because (a) they make promises before the election that they should not make (the promises are not credible and the electorate knows that) and (b) they break promises that they should not break to get into office. Not surprisingly, the electorate has contempt for them and punishes them at the subsequent election. FF and FG are identical parties so it is unlikely that either party would have to break a significant promise to go into government with the other. Consequently, the smaller party should not suffer at the subsequent general election.

Three seat constituencies
The highest first preference vote received by a Labour candidate who did not secure election in the 2011 general election was 17.56% in Limerick. The Labour candidate was in fourth place at the end of the first count but was 3% behind the third placed candidate (FF). The lowest first preference vote secured by a successful Labour candidate in 2011 (the sole Labour candidate in the constituency) was 14.31% in Cork South West.

Four seat constituencies
The highest first preference vote won by a Labour candidate in a four seat constituency who failed to be elected in 2011 was 11.75% in Cork North Central. The candidate was in sixth place at the end of the first count, less than 1% behind the fourth candidate elected. The lowest first preference vote secured by a successful Labour candidate in 2011 was 7.18% in Galway East. He was one of two Labour candidates in that constituency.

Five seat constituencies
The highest first preference vote secured by an unsuccessful Labour candidate in 2011 was 8.21% in Dublin South Central. In Wicklow, two of the three Labour candidates failed to be elected (the two candidates had a combined first preference vote of 9.43%). Had Labour run just two candidates they might have won two seats. The lowest first preference vote secured by a successful Labour candidate in 2011 was 7.71% in Wicklow, where, as stated above, there were three Labour candidates.

The Arms Industry

The head of the GMB union in Britain, Sir Paul Kenny, is opposed to Jeremy Corbyn's attempts to change Labour Party policy on Trident because it would affect the jobs of members of his union. He has threatened to mobilize workers at 50 defence industry sites across the UK to oppose any attempt by Labour to scrap Trident.

The ghastly position adopted by Kenny tells us a lot about the role of the arms industry in Western economies. (Kenny's knighthood tells us something about it too.) I don't know what percentage of the prosperity of developed economies (some anyway but they are all connected) is dependent on the arms industry but I think I once saw a figure of 25%. Whatever it is, it is significant.

The arms industry is now a key part (not far off being the only part) of what is left of Britain's manufacturing industry. Its influence on British foreign policy is enormous and deadly. In his article about the GMB union's opposition to scrapping Trident, in the Irish Times on 12th January, Denis Staunton failed to refer to the baleful influence of jobs in the arms industry on Britain's foreign policy. It is no coincidence that Britain has been to the forefront of every murderous policy being pursued by the West in recent years, including in Libya. They need the wars to preserve Britain's prosperity but the wars are getting closer to home.

In general, the media says little or nothing about the link between the arms industry and foreign policy, not always through wanting to bury the link but sometimes due to a simple failure to see the connection. It would help a great deal if economic history was a core subject at secondary level. It would teach everyone to make the necessary connection between economics and politics. It would also teach those who become senior journalists to probe issues that need probing and to bring to the surface the shocking link between the arms industry and the relentless wars that the arms industry demands. (Their editors and proprietors might not let them of course.) During the Cold War the arms industry (on both sides) was on to a good thing. They had a guaranteed market without (for the most part) the need for actual warfare although the Vietnam War was driven by the arms industry.

The end of the Cold War changed the situation and the the arms industry now needs (and is getting) hot wars all over the place. The fact that the wars are getting closer to home doesn't matter to the industry. Indeed, it helps their bottom line. The industry has no loyalty to any state or society (other than the need for societies to be sufficiently stable to allow them to pursue their murderous activities), only to profits. They are likely to welcome anything that boosts their profits. (58,000 dead US troops in Vietnam meant nothing to the arms industry as the figure was low enough not to generate a revolution and many of the dead were no doubt poor or black or probably both.) The next step is to ensure that their own societies are attacked (in a small way but big enough to generate an appropriate policy response from governments) as that will generate even more profits.

Joseph Heller's character, Milo Minderbinder, in Catch-22, captures the reality of the arms dealer perfectly. Heller deliberately and cleverly paints Milo as an attractive character but with something fundamental missing from his moral make-up. It is difficult for most of us to understand the mindset of the arms manufacturer and the arms dealer. We can't understand Milo Minderbinder's character in Catch-22 and we can't understand the amorality of the industry in real life either. We are not like them. Most people would recoil in horror at the thought that they were contributing to terrible suffering in the Middle East and elsewhere through the jobs held by their friends, neighbours and fellow citizens. It gets more difficult, however, when they have to be told that they will have to make a choice between generating wars in the Middle East or seeing their standard of living drop by 25%. So their governments and their media don't tell them. If, however, citizens were taught at school to think about the relationship between economics and politics it would make it more difficult to hide the horrors of the military industrial complex before it is too late.