Problems in the Health Service

Yet again today on the News at One, the Minister for Health was subjected to the usual questions about times on trollies, wards not open and so forth. It is easy for journalists to ask about the problem of SUPPY when they should be talking about the excess DEMAND for health services. I can't understand why politicians, who are on the receiving end of all this, never fight back. Is it because they haven't done their homework on the different levels of demand for health services in, say, Dublin and Manchester or, say, Dublin and Copenhagen? Why is the first fortnight of the year very demanding for the health service here? Is it in Manchester and Copenhagen also? Is it because people here have been consuming too much over Christmas and getting no exercise? If that is the case, why are the Government and the media not focusing on that problem? Is it all a game? The media play the role of the great crusaders. The politicians allow themselves to be humiliated in return for the media not asking the questions that are really relevant and that would oblige the Minister for Health, his Department and the HSE to address the real issues?

Has the Department of Health or the HSE (or the universities or the media) done any research on the nature of the demand for health services in this jurisdiction as opposed to other jurisdictions? How much of the bottlenecks that we constantly hear about has to do with our lifestyle, in particular the use and abuse of alcohol and other drugs, legal and illegal? Does the average citizen of Manchester or Copenhagen consume less alcohol than the average Dubliner? Are demands for A&E services in Manchester or Copenhagen less severe than in Dublin and is that a reflection of a healthier lifestyle among Mancunians and Danes? It shouldn't be too difficult to find that out and draw the necessary policy conclusions.

Do general practitioners in Manchester and Copenhagen look after their patients the way GPs once did here or are they just a referral service as seems to be the case here now? Do GPs do house calls in Manchester and Copenhagen unlike here as far as I can tell? A well functioning health service starts with citizens not living unhealthy and undisciplined lives (something their GPs should constantly remind them of as opposed to many GPs merely extracting large amounts of money from their patients every time their patients cross a surgery threshold). Why is the unhealthy lifestyle of so many people, frequently documented, not linked back to the problems with the provision of health care?

Why is their not more emphasis in the need to keep people away from hospitals and attending their GPs instead? There is no point in the Minister for Health making lame appeals on RTE. Action needs to be taken. Many GPs need to up their game, substantially. People need to be turned away from hospitals and referred back to their GPs, all of whom should have a facility for their patients to be seen 24 x 7. Why do hospitals permit GPs to refer patients for hospital attention when it is not always necessary? Why is the HSE not analysing the statistics to identify those GPs who are referring patients unnecessarily to hospital?

The main problem in the health service - which neither the media nor the politicians ever allude to - is that vested interests are more powerful than Government or the health service. Vested interests put their own interests first. That is not the case with the NHS in Britain. There are of course powerful health sector interests there but there is a sense (and I know this from my own experience) that the health service is more important than, and takes precedence over, the interests of the professions, trade unions and others who make up the service. The British Government has always seen itself as being above the vested interests and not as a referee managing the competing demands of the various interests, as is the case here. The weakness of the Government here in the face of strong vested interests is not just confined to the health service but (as with other sectors) politicians seem afraid to address the real issues and the media won't either. Using politicians as the national punchbag is easier for the media and politicians seem to be happy to play along.

Only in Ireland would this situation arise.


Bridge of Spies

I spent twenty four hours in Berlin in December 1989, one month after the Berlin Wall was opened. It was the most interesting twenty fours of my life. The sense of being at the end of WW2 (brilliantly captured in The Last Shot by Hugo Hamilton) permeated the city. I had a letter of introduction to a friend of a friend, who lived in East Berlin, so I crossed the border at Checkpoint Charlie. I rang the friend of a friend from East Berlin (I had tried to do so from West Berlin but was unable to get a connection). He told me to take the underground to a particular station where we met. I spent an interesting evening with him. He was a man of the left and took comfort from the fact that although the Wall had been breached the GDR still existed. I told him that I didn't think it would last for much longer. That was why I made the trip in December. I felt that by the following August - the month I normally went on holidays - the Wall or the GDR or both would be gone. The Wall was, as far as I remember.

I had to be back at Checkpoint Charlie by midnight or wait until the next morning to get back to West Berlin. I couldn't find my way back from the underground station but a local guy guided me through the narrow streets to the Wall. We were running like hell to make it. I felt like I was in The Spy Who Came In From the Cold or The Iprcess File. (A colleague in the office subsequently spread a story that the Russians had opened up on me. A few weeks earlier they would have!) I always regretted that I never even shook hands with my guide. I got back to Checkpoint Charlie at about 12.05 but there were a few other people there so they let us all through. On the West Berlin side, an Englishwoman, who said she was a dentist working in West Berlin (but in retrospect was probably a member of MI6), gave me a lift back to my hotel.

The next morning I headed straight for the Wall at the Old Reichstag near the Brandenburg Gate. (Presumably, the German Parliament is back there again.) I didn't know until then that the Wall was not the border, which extended for another six feet west of the Wall. This was to allow the GDR to police both sides of the Wall. (When an East Berlin policeman was patrolling on the western side of the Wall he was watched by an armed colleague.) I joined a large group of people who were chipping bits out of the Wall. (I got my piece mounted and still have it.) At some point during the morning, the East Berlin police emerged out of a gate and began to patrol the western side of the Wall. The chatting stopped, the tension mounted (not, however, to a dangerous level) and most people, including me, stepped back inside the barriers, which were placed there by the West Berlin police, I think, and marked the frontier between West and East Berlin. A few people, however, didn't stop and one woman lost her hammer to an East Berlin policeman. She had drawn back her right hand ready to hit the Wall (whatever it was made of it was not easy to knock bits out of) but he deftly took the hammer out of her hand and threw it over the Wall.  A few moments later, the East Berlin police reached the river (the Spee, I think), got into conversation with someone who looked like a notable of some sort, the tension dropped and we all went back to hacking on the Wall.

Steven Spielberg's film captures the atmosphere of Cold War Berlin very well, it seems to me, although I only experienced its dying embers. East Berlin was certainly a grim place, a complete contrast to the bright lights of West Berlin. Spielberg doesn't just capture the atmosphere of the city and the times but he also captures the absurdity of what was going on. He doesn't (?) set out to do this. He just tells the story of the swap of two spies but the Cold War, although dangerous and, at times, highly dangerous, was largely bogus (and mostly stable). The Cold War was largely driven by the military industrial complex of the West in pursuit of careers for generals and spooks, and profits for the arms manufacturers. I felt its bogus nature at the time, and it is even more obvious in retrospect just how fake it was. The MI Complex has no Cold War now so has had to resort to generating hot wars in Iraq, Afghanistan and Syria to keep their profits up (which was the main purpose of the Vietnam War, the main hot conflict of the Cold War).

In some ways (and this too I felt at the time) there was an absurdity about the Cold War. Spielberg's film, again not consciously it seems to me, captures this very well. Vast amounts of treasure were wasted and not a few lives were lost (58,000 US troops in Vietnam alone but over a million Vietnamese citizens, guerrillas and soldiers) keeping the US MI Complex in profits. The great and the good of the West went along with it and the legal system was distorted by it. People's rights were trampled on, rights that Americans proclaimed then and now to be what the US was about but that its legislature, its court and its media ignored. It was ugly.

In the West, we were programmed to believe that the Russians cracked the whip and all of eastern Europe jumped. It was never that simple. The Russians dominated their alliance just as the US dominated NATO but other parties, like the GDR and indeed the Poles, also had skin in the game. They had their own agendas. Spielberg captures this very well, again without making a big deal of it. He lets the events tell the story. It would be interesting to see a good film maker (and Spielberg is the best there is; he will be considered by future generations as the Shakespeare of the 20th century) do a story on the tension between the West German State and the NATO powers that were "protecting" it.

Mark Rylance, who plays the Soviet spy being exchange for Gary Powers, gives one of the best film performances of the year. Despite the foolishness and absurdity of the Cold War (there is only one letter of a difference between "cold" and "cod"!), there were deeply committed people on both sides, although it has to be said that, in the West, most of the committed people were fools or knaves. There was no excuse for them not to see through what was going on. In a system as cruel and totalitarian as the USSR, and as lacking in the good things of life (compared to the West), those genuinely committed to it had to be people of high calibre. Rylance's performance captures that kind of integrity. Tom Hanks' performance is up to his usual excellent standard.

It is only twenty six years since the Wall was opened but it might as well have been 250 for all the relevance the Wall and the Cold War have to today's fast-changing world. In 1989, the US and the USSR dominated the world. Now the US is offering to "share" the world with China, which recognizes that kind of  pleading as a defeated opponent trying to stay in the game.

So, all has changed, changed utterly but you couldn't say that a terrible beauty has been born. I feel a certain nostalgia for the Cold War (but I haven't forgot its ugliness) and recommend Bridge of Spies to anyone who feels the same way.




Standards in public office, i.e. RTE

I never cease to be amazed by politicians who get caught in journalistic stings, about which I have reservations. That said, of the three cases highlighted, the Monaghan county councillor's behaviour was so outrageous that he might indeed have realized it was a sting. The other two were sailing close to the wind but I'm not sure if their actions could be said to constitute breaches of any code or something more serious. The Donegal county councillor is very young and certainly needs to grow up. No doubt he has grown up a lot since last night. 

People in this State are never happier than when they are unhappy about the state of ... well the State. The RTE programme last night threw up three cases of possible improper behaviour but RTE acted as if they had found 300 councillors with their hands in the till. It seems that the programme makers contacted a number of other councillors who refused to play ball - either because they didn't fall for the sting or for some other reason. RTE, however, didn't tell us how many councillors there are in the State, how many they had contacted and how many had refused to talk to them. Any serious and responsible programme maker would have provided that information at the beginning of the programme to allow the viewers to appreciate the scale of the alleged wrong doing uncovered. Perhaps RTE would have provided the information if the number of councillors falling for the sting had been more numerous. Three is a derisory number.

Listening to Fintan O'Toole on Prime Time afterwards, who should perhaps be styled the National Professor of Verbal Diarrhoe, you would think that wholesale corruption had been uncovered. There is only so much of O'Toole I can put up so I didn't watch the whole of the Prime Time programme afterwords. I don't know if either of the panelists or anyone in the audience questioned RTE about their failure to provide the public with the basic statistics referred to in the previous paragraph without which the programme was meaningless.

It is hard to avoid the conclusion that having spent nearly a year (?) preparing the programme and having discovered very little RTE were determined to make the most of it and blew it out of all proportion. They should perhaps be more worried about their own standards than those of the local authorities.

The New Ireland Forum, the ESRI and Brexit

The recent ESRI publication on Brexit ("Scoping the Possible Economic Implications of Brexit on Ireland") does not appear to include any references, in relation to North/South issues, to the work of the New Ireland Forum of the 1980s. The bibliography indeed contains only six references to 20th century publications -

- A 1998 publication on how foreign direct investment (FDI) affects economic growth
- A 1997 publication on the growth of FDI in Europe
- A 1996 publication on market share and exchange rate pass-through in world automobile trade
- A 1989 publication about tariffs and exchange rates under imperfect competition, and
- Two publications by the (current but not at the time) Governor of the Central Bank from 1982 and
  1984 on unemployment in Ireland.

Many of the publications cited in the bibliography appear to be by authors from outside Ireland with a strong emphasis on FDI. We have put so many eggs in the FDI basket that it has distorted our capacity to make good policy decisions in other areas.

The following documents published by the New Ireland Forum would appear to be relevant to the North/South aspects of Brexit but don't appear to have been examined by the ESRI:

- The Economic Consequences of the Division of Ireland since 1920
- A Comparative Description of the Economic Structure and Situation, North and South
- Integrated Policy and Planning for Transport in a New Ireland
- Opportunities for North/South Co-Operation in Energy
- An Analysis of Agricultural Developments in the North and South of Ireland and of the Effects of
   Integrated Policy and Planning, and
- The Macroeconomic Consequences of Integrated Economic Policy, Planning and Co-ordination in
   Ireland.

A great deal of work went into the preparation of those reports for what was a major national initiative (that led to the Anglo Irish Agreement (1985) and subsequently to the Downing Street Declaration and the Good Friday Agreement (both 1990s)). It seems strange that New Ireland Forum documents were not consulted during the preparation of the ESRI document, which states that all its Research Series reports are peer reviewed prior to publication. The ESRI report has a chapter on energy so it is particularly odd that the Forum research on energy is not cited. The authors of the report appear to have had contact with the Department of Finance but they don't say if they had contact with any other Department.

In addition to the New Ireland Forum, the authors don't appear to have consulted "Border Crossings, Developing Ireland's Island Economy", edited by Michael D'Arcy and Tim Dickson (1995), which includes a chapter by a (then) research professor at the ESRI, or Alan Gray's book (also 1995) "The Economic Consequences of Peace in Ireland". Nor does it mention the seminal Opsahl Report ("A Citizens' Inquiry, The Opsahl Report on Northern Ireland") edited by Andy Pollak (1993), which contains an important piece on the economy.

I haven't found any reference to the work of the Nordic Council either. The Nordic Council contains states that are (a) in the EU and the Eurozone, (b) in the EU but not the Eurozone and (c) in neither. The work of the Nordic Council would surely provide some guidance to how relations between Britain and Ireland could be managed in a situation where Brexit occurs.



Addiction

Ruairi McKiernan's article in today's Irish Times, Natasha Eddery has shattered the national silence on alcoholism, explores some important issues to do with addiction, some of which are relevant to Irish society while others are relevant to societies in general. If Ireland is an addictive society, which it is, there are reasons particular to the Irish character that causes addiction. They include a lack of steadiness and a lack of self-discipline. The Irish character tends to be weak and, as a consequence, wild.

We tend to be sensitive about criticism of the Irish abroad in places like the UK, the US or Australia. We shouldn't, as the criticism is based on the lived experience of the people there. We tend to see a hint of racism in the criticism as the travelling people here do about the criticism of them by settled people. The plain reality is that there is an element of racism in the criticism but we have no one to blame but ourselves. Racism has now largely gone underground but certain events are likely to trigger racist comments. When OJ Simpson was on trial for the murder of his wife, Jay Leno, on the Tonight Show, used it as an excuse to make jokes that he would not otherwise have got away with. When the students were killed and injured in Berkeley some months ago (in an accident where the students were not at fault), the New York Times saw fit to make the kind of comments about the Irish that would have been ten a penny in the paper fifty years ago but that can't easily be expressed now. The paper was obviously dying to have a go at the Irish, something that is, I believe, always just below the surface in the NYT.

Angela's Ashes got rave reviews in the US as it was a way of good old-fashioned Irish-bashing. The author should have realized that. Perhaps he did but went along with it for commercial reasons. It was very obviously a gift to the NYT and others and they were not prepared to look a gift horse in the mouth. Literature is often used by the media and others outside Ireland as a way of indulging in good old-fashioned anti-Irish sentiment. We don't seem to be as aware of that as we should be.

The behavior of our emigrants in the past was generally very good and brought great credit on themselves and on this country. Their behaviour, courage, hard work and sticking by the old religion, often in the face of discrimination, generated a great deal of (admittedly often grudging) respect and countered the deep anti-Irish racism that was a natural part of the make-up of the establishments in the US and the British Empire. They were, after all, basically English states. There was, no doubt, wild behaviour by enough of our emigrants to keep the stereotypes alive but overall the majority of our emigrants, by their behaviour, successfully countered the stereotypes.

It is ironic or paradoxical or something that the first generations of better educated and reasonably well off Irish travelling abroad to work or to explore the world (including countries that were traditionally well disposed to Ireland) have rekindled the stereotypes of the Irish as wild and drunken. Watching the Irish abroad myself, it is clear that there is much truth in the criticisms of them. Many of the Irish abroad now are very unattractive in their behaviour. They are not aware of it because they are ignorant and the collapse of religious practice has removed a certain level of restraint and self-discipline that was a positive feature of the behaviour of most Irish abroad in the past. Lastly, many young Irish today (at home and abroad) have a diminished capacity to see themselves as others do. That seems to be a consequence of modern parenting, which appears to leave a lot to be desired. You frequently see the opposite to over confidence (bordering on boorishness) in youngsters who are working for solid organizations that have core values, including courtesy. The contrast between those who clearly are aware of the need for courtesy and those who are not (a contrast that did not exist fifty years ago) can at times be striking. It is sad to think that the hard work and struggle of millions of poor emigrants over two hundred years is in danger of being undone by the excesses of our time but that could be the case.

It is up to us to address the excess in our behaviour (at home and abroad) that generate criticism. That must begin not by talking about alcoholism (Natasha Eddery's article won't result in one less pint of beer being consumed in Ireland tonight) but by recognizing the deep flaws in the Irish character, which have always been there and explain much of our history. We blame the Normans/English/British for our miserable history. We should blame ourselves for being weak and for not evicting the intruders centuries ago.

The collapse of religious practice is a factor that needs to be mentioned in trying to grapple with the problem of excess that is the other side of the coin to a weak character. Religious practice imposes rules and teaches people self discipline, whether it is not to drink too much or not to cheat on a spouse. The rules have gone and have not yet been replaced by a new set of secular rules.

Ireland may be an island but we live in a globalized world. Our weak character and addictive nature are extreme but capitalism and the promotion of goods and services are contributing significantly to the destruction of Western societies everywhere. Tackling that problem would make climbing Mount Everest appear like a stroll up to Faery Castle from Tibradden!

The Refugee/Migrant Crisis

It would help if people writing about the refugee crisis put it into context. The Middle East is an unstable area, there have long been tensions between Shias and Sunnis to say nothing about the fact that the place is not exactly the home of democracy. In addition, however, the behaviour of Western powers in the area starting (well whenever you like but let’s say) with


  • the Balfour Declaration of 1917 and moving on to,
  • the carve up of the Ottoman Empire between Britain and France after WW1,
  • the understandable but utterly wrong decision to create a Western state out of Palestine in 1948 (Israel will probably survive as long as its predecessor, the Crusader state, did),
  • the appalling treatment of the Palestinians by Israel supported by the West since 1948,
  • the Western coup in Iran in 1953
  • the foolish decision to invade Afghanistan after “9/11”. Although that atrocity conferred no right on the US to invade anyone, if they had to pick a state it should have been the state where most of the bombers came from – Saudi Arabia
  • the savagery (and illegality) of the West’s actions in Iraq since 2003,
  • Britain and France’s decision to get rid of Gadaffi in the 00s probably to protect arms sales to what they (foolishly) thought might be a post Gadaffi democracy (the Russians and the Chinese will never fall for that one again; I was surprised that they fell for that stunt), and
  • whatever you’re having yourself!

has to be included in any meaningful writing about the tragedy of the refugees and the migrants. It would also help if the West acknowledged its mistakes and its crimes and furthermore admitted that the driving force behind its actions in the Middle East today (as with imperialism always), is money. In today’s circumstances, concerns about oil supplies and the need for arms manufacturers to keep making profits are the critical factors. Everyone recognizes the importance of the oil industry to our standard of living and the need for security of oil supplies but it is not necessary to engage in savage violence anywhere to secure oil supplies. What has changed, even since the 1960s/70s, is the extent to which the arms industry in the West has got out of control. President Eisenhower, himself a former soldier, recognized the need to curb the Military Industrial Complex, which I have always believed was behind the Kennedy assassination (and which is why no US President since then has dared to challenge it), and his words of warning have come home to roost.

Although views like mine could be construed as coming from the broad left (or at least the peace movement, which I have supported all my life), they are not really. The refugee/migrant crisis is not a left, right or centre issue or even a peace movement issue. It is a critical issue resulting from the fact that Western states have lost control of hugely powerful interests to which they gave birth (such as the arms industry – TTIP is another example). If Western states don’t regain control over those interests the consequences for the West itself will be huge (and, frankly, deserved).

The treatment of religious minorities in the Middle East should be evidence enough of the nature of the challenge we face and who the bad guys are. The arms industry couldn’t care less if their bombs are killing Christians, Moslems, Hindus or Presbyterian Buddhists! (Remember Milo Minderbinder in Catch-22?) The arms industry is completely amoral and its only interests are sales and profits. Most people in the West are not (that) amoral and if the media joined up the dots the people of the West would see the scale of the challenge we face to get these vested interests under control. Even if public opinion does turn against the arms industry, however, it won’t be plain sailing. The arms industry, the drugs trade and the sex industry (including, it has to be said Hollywood, the theatre and, up to a point, the mainstream media), supported by the banking industry (governments know that genuine efforts to curb the activities of drug traffickers, for example, would seriously damage the banking industry) represent the very depths to which humanity can sink. They are today’s equivalent of the people William Wilberforce tackled and defeated. The arms industry is legal, the sex industry is legal in part and the drugs industry is tolerated. The banks are also legal and are backed up by private and public sector regulators, many of whom, like the bankers and no doubt even some of the arms peddlers, are respectable, church going people. Respectable church-going people some of them may be but try taking them on! It will be a long hard slog. Wilberforce did it with the slave trade and another Wilberforce (Pope Francis?) is needed now.

So, it is not just a case of identifying illegality (the drugs trade) or the amorality of the arms trade. Western society has become deeply corrupted by much of what has gone on since WW2 and, in particular, since the Swinging Sixties, and is now very decadent. Unfortunately, however, because of the link between the activities of the arms (in particular) industry and our standard of living, not all commentators, in particularly conservative commentators, are prepared to say what has to be said. For conservatives (much more than for the left), class loyalties predominate. Pope Francis is possibly a key player in this. Will he call it as it needs to be called or will he play the game? I think he will play  the game. I think he is playing the game.

So, how do you get conservative leaders and opinion formers in the West to break their class loyalties and challenge the vested interests (with or without the help of the Pope)? Until that happens, calling for Christian enclaves in the Middle East (does that mean everyone else is fair game?) or saying we will only admit Christian refugees to the EU is neither here nor there. The problem is here, in our world, not in the Middle East or North Africa. The West is where the bad guys are and they are every bit as wicked as Hitler and the Nazis.

Merkel and the Refugee/Migrant Crisis

It is ironic to hear David Cameron saying that there is a need to tackle the cause of the conflict in Syria when he was gung-ho for bombing the Assad regime out of existence just two years ago - until he was stopped by Red Ed in a House of Commons vote, which in turn, stopped the Americans joining in. If Assad had been got rid of it would have made the Syrian situation infinitely worse with many more Christians either fleeing or having their throats cut. I see that Cameron is going to try again to bomb Syria - this time ISIS, I think. The man should make up his mind who his friends are and who his enemies are!

Cameron's weaknesses are being cruelly exposed but in fairness to him he is riding several tigers at the one time. Britain is more hostile to non-white immigration than many countries, partly because that is the way they are (it is the other side of the nature that resulted in the creation of a powerful empire) and partly because they are now experiencing the consequences of large-scale immigration of non-whites from their former empire. The bottom line is that every state must make its own decisions about immigration but a liberal democracy should be expected to do so in a liberal and humane way.

The British, however, are seeing their country and their society change before their eyes so their anger is hardly a surprise. Given the imperial roots of the problem, I don't have huge sympathy for the British but I do recognize a political problem when I see it. Cameron is also trying to keep the UK in the EU and the Scots in the UK. He shouldn't worry about the EU. It is slowly collapsing but the Scots' situation is deeply worrying as the recent vote there was only half time. So, I have some sympathy for him.

Derek Scally's information (Wednesday 26 August, IT) was interesting:

"German politicians rarely visit these areas [i.e. east German areas where there is high unemployment and where people feel threatened  by heavy immigration], nor do they have answers to German involvement in the causes of the refugee crisis. Such as how, in the first half of 2015 alone, Germany green-lighted arms exports worth €6.35 billion  - almost as much  as in the entire calendar year 2014. Arms exports to Arab states and northern Africa - from where millions of people are fleeing - more than doubled to €587 million...".

I'm surprised the editor of the IT permitted Scally's figures to be published but they have generated no traction nor will they, for the present. The public is upset by the sight of the dead child on the beach in Turkey (and rightly so) and is not, for the moment, interested in reading about the West's part in the Syrian tragedy or the tragedy of the wider Middle East going back to the foundation of the State of Israel. That will come but the timing will need to be right.

Likewise, if NATO had not bombed Libya's Gadaffi out of existence there would not now be emigrants trying to cross the Mediterranean from Libya. Gadaffi could easily have been induced to see to that. The media and commentators generally are not making that connection because they failed to say, at the time, that the overthrow of Gadaffi was a serious breach of international law. It was an act of outright NATO aggression, a throwback to 19th century imperialism. There is no doubt that Gadaffi would have slaughtered every man, woman and child in Benghazi, which is why the UN permitted NATO to stop him from doing so. NATO, however, was not empowered to overthrow Gadfaffi. Nor was it necessary for NATO plans to protect Benghazi. Arab League and/or African Union air forces  - or even the Russians and the Chinese air forces - could have done it. (The Russians and the Chinese should have insisted on that at the UN Security Council. I don't know why they didn't.) The fact that NATO overthrew Gadaffi, which was designed to protect British and French arms sales to the "democratic" government that Cameron and Sarko believed would replace Gadaffi in the Arab Spring, was a significant feature, I suspect, in Putin's decision to annex the Crimea. He saw NATO engaging in imperialism in Africa so he decided to do the same in his neighbourhood. The Soviet invasion of Hungary in 1956 followed the Suez fiasco. The media didn't make the connection then and they are not making it now.

Merkel has agreed to take 800,000 refugees/migrants because (as per Suzanne Lynch's article in the IT on Saturday ("Migrant issue poses a threat to EU unity")) if she didn't the crisis could break the EU apart. (It might anyway.) Merkel is getting the credit ("slate for 1939-45 wiped clean", etc.) from people who should know better. She is acting to protect Germany's very own imperial project. I note that she is beginning to get some flack from her Bavarian colleagues but no doubt public opinion in Germany will see her through that particular hiccup. It will take time and good journalism (!)  for people to realize that Merkel is acting in her own interests, not in the interests of the migrants (although no doubt she feels for them as the rest of us do).

I don't know if the migrants will stay in Germany or move around but Schengen should be abandoned. My guess is that if it will have to be, making the migrant issue the second major pressure point leading to a break-up of the EU. The third will be Russia.

Apparently, on a per capita basis (i.e. our share of the EU's population), we should take 10,000 refugees/migrants. We could take 5,000 without too much difficulty. As one of the editorials in the papers said yesterday (I think it was the SBP), it might mean postponing more money for the HSE or roads or whatever but we can do it. My guess is that within a few years the Exchequer would be benefiting from the 5,000. No one would expect us to take 40,000, the same proportion as Germany, because we are not trying to build a European empire, as is Germany. We could, however, take 5,000.