Trump and Trump haters

Marian Finucane interviewed a Trump supporter, an Irishwoman living in Virginia, who is a member of the Virginia Women for Trump Group, on her RTE radio show this morning. The woman, a well-heeled Dubliner, by the sound of her, who is not a teenager and will have seen US Presidents come and go, was rational and reasonable. She was very conservative, as you would expect, intelligent and articulate. And well capable of arguing her case. I was particularly impressed by what she said about Trump and the widow of the army sergeant killed in action recently. She didn’t blame the widow for the row (fully empathizing with her grief, as Trump, in his blundering way, also tried to do) but was very critical of the Congresswoman for her involvement. Spot on. 

I think I heard her saying that Hilary Clinton won 58 counties in the Presidential election and Trump won 3,000 but I might have got that wrong. Ms. Finucane asked her about Trump’s tweets. Her response was that, before Trump, everyone was complaining about a lack of transparency in government. Trump uses Twitter, she said, to tell people what he thinks. True, but that doesn’t mean he always has to. A good leader keeps 90% of what is in his head to himself.
 
What was really interesting was the response of Ms. Finucane's panel when asked, by Marian, to comment on the woman’s views. The first member of the panel described the woman, to her face (as it were), as ignorant. She dealt with that. Another member of the panel said something even worse (I half missed it) forcing Ms. Finucane to step in and say “hold on a moment there”. It was vintage debate, Irish style – ignorant and intolerant although not by Marian, who did what an interviewer should do, ask the questions and let the interviewee answer without being insulted. Marian did say that the views the woman expressed are not normally heard on this side of the Atlantic, which is true. Some panelists extended the basic courtesy to the woman that is meant to be applied in debates but is absent where Trump is concerned (and indeed increasingly where elites are challenged). Trump is usually blamed for that but his opponents have matched him all the way. The intolerance of the elite is something we all have to live with whether it is forcing EU treaties down our throats whether we voted for them or not or coming up with parliamentary committees, whose decisions are made before they meet, to force through abortion. 

The arrogance and contempt of the US elite for ordinary people is what catapulted Trump into the White House (what will happen here, I wonder?) but there is no sign of the establishment here or anywhere else reflecting on that.

 

Pride comes before a fall

The Hollywood crowd should have spotted the omen at the last Oscars when Bonnie and Clyde made a mistake in announcing the winner of an Oscar. It followed an evening where they had all been having fun at Trump’s expense with Meryl Streep (who mistook Weinstein for God on another occasion) playing a central role. The lights went out at the Oscars, if I recall, that night, which should have been a signal to dial down the arrogance but they didn’t take the hint so now they have got fate’s response full on. Not to mention that a Hollywood actor doing anything other than acting is a complete bore. A bit like Bono .... [Memo to Streep and Bono: there is no law against silence and there is no law against keeping it simple when you do speak.]
 
It’s hard to say whether the Weinstein business will shut Hollywood up when it comes to lecturing Trump and the rest of us or whether it will all blow over in a week or two. There is no question of Hollywood and sex separating. If you take sex out of Hollywood you might as well take the cameras out too. Hollywood, like the theatre from which it emerged, is all about sex. However, a scapegoat is required every now and again, I suppose, and Weinstein fits the bill perfectly. I’d never heard of Weinstein until last week but he makes Trump look like a charming, handsome, JFK-type figure ....
 
I suspect that Weinstein is Jewish, which must have given the NYT a headache or two before they went to print. No doubt they will do a major piece shortly on a bad boy Catholic bishop to get Weinstein off the front page.

George Hook falls foul of McCarthyism

The case of George Hook is a classic case of someone falling foul of McCarthyism. He may be “colourful” but he is entitled to his opinion. The world is, to be blunt, over-sexed, hyper-sexed in fact, and the sex industry (all the way from suggestive photographs every Sunday on the cover of the SINDO magazine to hard core pornography) is now one of the world's most powerful industries. 

Once money – on a vast scale – becomes part of any industry it becomes a very powerful industry and very difficult to challenge. Anyone wishing to challenge the sex industry is going to have to be smarter than George Hook. They are going to have to find a way past the moral policemen of the Iveagh House Bulletin, Crown Forces Times and Whatever You’re Having Yourself Matrimonially- Speaking Newsletter. They are going to have to find a way of saying that the male of the species is like the male of any species - always looking for sexual encounters. They are going to have to find a way of saying that women need to be aware of the raw threat from the male of the species in how they comport themselves and in the situations they get into. That has implications for everything from fashion to film and from education to social life. We will have to wait for something to happen, some trigger that will allow rational argument back into the debate about the sexual mores of our time.
 

It’s a bit like Trump: the forces that Trump threatened (globalization, perpetual war for perpetual peace [profits], the abortion lobby) mobilized the world media industry to try to stop him. They failed but the military industrial complex and the secret state have – for the moment at any rate – crushed Trump’s efforts to re-engineer US foreign policy away from war-making and naked imperialism. By the same token, powerful vested interests are able to ensure that anyone who challenges the sex industry will be crushed. You would think that someone like Fintan O’Toole could spot that and see what Hook was trying to say in his muddled fashion but they don’t seem to be able to. Smart people are being manipulated by powerful forces and they don’t even know it. Plus, there is, I think, a natural urge to McCarthyism, a natural desire to seize any opportunity to silence the opposition if you can. All the better if you can dress your intolerance up as something else.

Brexit: British/Irish Relations (House of Lords Report)

There can be no question of people in Northern Ireland not retaining the right to Irish citizenship after Brexit so the House of Lords is wrong to even raise the issue. They obviously don’t realize that anyone born anywhere in the world with at least one Irish grandparent is entitled to Irish citizenship. That said, the House of Lords is telling the Department of Foreign Affairs that the Irish Government should not be running around Europe pleading for the right of people in Donegal to travel to Derry without a visa after Brexit. Apart from making fools of themselves, there is a risk of the Europeans (the other 26 Member States) stirring up trouble for both Britain and the Republic in terms of cross-border and east-west relations, trouble that the other 26 would not normally contemplate causing. They might, however, cause trouble in order to put pressure on the British Government in the Brexit talks or indeed on the Irish Government to leave the EU with the British.

It is possible that officials in the Department of Foreign Affairs are doing their best to stop Kenny and Flanagan running around Europe making fools of themselves. I don’t know but the House of Lords report will be seen by the Department (if not by their political masters) and by other foreign ministries, inside and outside the EU, as a telling off for the way Kenny and Flanagan are behaving. I have no doubt that the British Foreign Office will have urged the HoL to publish the report, and quickly (the first of five or six this week from the HoL), before Kenny and Flanagan do more damage. The weakness of both men is being shown up starkly. In the nature of these things, PM May can’t tell Kenny to stop making a fool of himself. It would also be difficult for the Foreign Office to say that to the Ambassador, even informally, but the message is coming through loud and clear in the report.

The House of Lords report will be seen by the other 26 Member States as a typical divide and conquer move by the British. There is truth in that but from our point of view divide and conquer is the right approach on this occasion.

The House of Lords report talks about any bilateral deal being approved by the EU after it has been agreed by Britain and Ireland. That is diplomatic-speak for telling the EU to take it or leave it. 

A very important report.

Housing Policy

With all the talk about mortgage rules, it was left to Colm McCarthy in yesterday's Sunday Independent to make the most important point of all: the failure of our housing policy is not down to the Central Bank but to the Department of the Environment, the planning authorities and their political masters. Although the Central Bank deserves criticism for the runaway chaos of the 00s, the principal failure down through the decades has been by the political system. As McCarthy said, housing policy is the responsibility of the Government, not of the Central Bank, but because of our dysfunctional political system the Central Bank has been asked to do the heavy lifting. It can't.

When was the last time the Taoiseach, the Minister for Finance, the Minister for Housing or any Minister told the public that the price of houses should remain stable in real terms? When have Ministers spoken about the need for housing policy to be set in a wider context of economic and social development, including climate change? When have Ministers told the public that urban sprawl and the waste of good farm land has to be brought to an end and that people will have to live in cities (not commute every morning from ever expanding suburbs). The energy cost, the carbon footprint and the damage done to the fabric of cities (not to mention the quality of life of commuters) demands a major change of approach.

The Irish approach to housing is well captured by the ESB advertisement about the young man heading home for Christmas, bring greeted at the bus station by his father and being driven home to his house in the countryside to be greeted by his mother. It is an experience many people can relate to but it is a lifestyle that will have to change. The idea that work and home should be in different places (even if the advertisement is probably about a student) must be challenged. The majority of the population will have to adjust to living in urban areas within walking or cycling distance of their place of work, or, at worst, a short journey by public transport from within the town or city limits. Children should walk to school or at best go by school bus. Parents should be strongly discouraged or, if necessary, forbidden by law to bring children to school by car (especially by SUV!).

Planning permission should be closely linked to issues of density, public transport, schools and other factors. The question of price controls will have to be considered, if only to deal with the problems of development. Whereas in the past a "good" area of a town or city was home to a wide range of middle class professions and activities, nowadays, in effect, only doctors, lawyers, accountants and financial services personnel can afford to live in certain areas and send their children to the perceived top schools. This not only creates resentment among, say, senior public servants and teachers it also discourages people from choosing a career in the public service or teaching. That, in turn, impacts on economic and social development in two ways: we will have too many doctors, lawyers, etc. (not all of them suited to those professions) and not enough good public servants, teachers, etc.

House prices and the belief throughout Irish society that housing is the route to (unearned) wealth is a deeply ingrained cultural trait in what is a very greedy society and it will not be easy to change. Not surprisingly, public representatives are not prepared to address the greed factor but they will have to sooner or later. House prices have had a huge impact on other areas of public policy, including pay demands and the capacity of the State to provide much needed services. The high cost of living is a result of the greedy nature of Irish society, which won't be successfully tackled until we have a functioning housing policy. Changing cultural habits like greed are of course a lot more difficult to effect than changing mortgage rules but because we have 100 TDs too many the political class won't even try. The problems are mounting up, however, right across virtually every area of public policy and the common denominator - the dysfunctional political system, which needs massive pruning - will have to be addressed.








Why Trump?

There is a great deal more to be said about the election and it will be a very long time before the fallout is complete. There are going to be consequences on many levels but the most urgent one has to be the economy. The media on this side of the Atlantic said that HC’s campaign was slick and that Trump’s gallop through some of the “marginal constituencies” like Pennsylvania in the last few days before the election was a sign of desperation. The opposite seems to have been the case. HC’s campaign appears to have been driven by identity politics, by the type of people who believe the main subject for discussion on university campuses should be genderless bathrooms, whereas Trump seems to have had a well organized campaign that listened to what ordinary citizens were saying. If HC had had any sense at all she would have broadly endorsed Trump’s approach to trade and globalization (not that many people would have believed her). If the Democratic Party does not move immediately to do so now (along the lies of Bernie Sanders) it could well be toast. There is room for a genuine left of centre party to replace the Democrats and to focus on the issues of concern to tens of millions of ordinary Americans. 

Politics is all about the haves and the havenots. The haves are always well represented. The havenots don’t usually get much of a look in but when the party that is supposed to represent them goes farther to the right than the candidate of the haves what else are the voters to do? You could argue that the US empire will have to be brought to an end before US politics can be reformed but assuming that reform is possible within the imperial structure the Democrats have to rediscover what a left of centre political party is about: ensuring that ordinary citizens have a decent job, a decent standard of living, decent healthcare, decent unemployment benefit when out of work, decent housing and so on. Trump took that ground, and in my view honestly so. The same thing happened in 1860 when Lincoln stole the progressive ground of the anti-slavery movement admittedly because the Republican Party wanted strong tariffs in the North and the Southern States didn’t so there was a natural alliance between the various wings of the Republican party that brought about the end of slavery. Nevertheless, Lincoln’s abhorrence of slavery was genuine and the honour of destroying slavery and the rotten social and economic system that underpinned it and benefited from it fell to the Republican Party. The same might happen in relation to excessive globalization. If Bernie Sanders had been selected by the Democrats he would have beaten Trump. He might indeed have beaten Trump and Clinton if he had opted to run. 

I’m not too bothered about Trump’s boorish behaviour. My guess is that he calculated that the only way he could channel the anger into votes was by turning up the volume. This was no ordinary election and if the US elite does not take heed of what happened who knows what will happen in the future. Trump also realized that after fifty years of PC (much of it justified certainly but it had gone way off the rails with the gender stuff and the bathrooms and university students wanting safe rooms) it was necessary to challenge it and challenge it aggressively. He was clearly right on both counts although it was ugly. It will now be up to him to turn down the volume.

There was a good article on the election in the NYT The End of Identity Liberalism by Mark Lilla, who is essentially saying that gender stuff and bathroom stuff has its place but front and centre: no. Anyone with any cop-on has been saying this right through the campaign but not HC’s people. Apparently, Bill Clinton tried to get this across to them but was told to button it. Apparently, he also told them not to ignore the Catholic vote but the latent anti-Catholicism of HC, a good WASP, came through. In many ways it was the mirror image of Trump’s attack on PC. Clinton and her people felt that they had a licence for good old fashioned Catholic-bashing dressed up as something else. They forgot that good old-fashioned Catholics have votes. HC’s arrogance and sense of entitlement to the Presidency let her down and her friends in the media, who should have warned her, didn’t.

Trump’s election will have an impact on feminism. There is now a divide between those who argue for women’s rights and those who argued that HC had a right to power because she is a woman. That was quite a leap for the sisterhood to make and it was important that she lose on that ground alone. If the sisterhood splits big time over this I would expect “approved” opinions about abortion among right-on types to start diverging too.

It remains to be seen if the military industrial complex and the secret state prevent Trump from making significant changes to US war policy, which, again, I suspect he genuinely wants to make. I suspect that he is opposed to the elite’s policy of perpetual war for perpetual profits for the arms industry (with the morons in the State Department and the satellite think tanks going along with them). It would be a brave man who would predict success for Trump there.

I sent a tweet to the actor who lectured Pence after a theatre performance asking the actor, Dixon, if he had lectured HC in the same patronizing way about her destabilizing of Libya. No response needless to say but I see some tweets coming through about Dixon urging black guys to have sex with white women on Paddy’s Day. If you are going to lecture the Vice President Elect you would be well to have a clean sheet yourself as, if you don’t, someone will dig up the dirt. That is what has happened to Dixon. I don’t expect the New York Times to lecture Dixon about his attitude to white women or a file to be sent to the Director of Public Prosecutions (as we say) but Dixon, who is an eejit, might come to regret his fifteen minutes of fame.

The Donald trumps Brexit

The election count was a close replica of Brexit night although it went on longer. The similarities indeed were uncanny. The "Sunderland" of last night was Ohio.Trump's win there suggested that a Trump victory was possible. Had he won Virginia as well, which he almost did, I would have got to bed a lot sooner than 7am! As it was, the US networks waited two hours or more to move Trump's electoral college votes from 244 to the 270s (bar one vote to 245). One doesn't want to get paranoid but 99% of the votes had been counted in Pennsylvania, I think, with Trump in the lead (and therefore over the 270 number) but, even though the New York Times had called it, the networks refused to do so for about two hours. I suspect that if Pennsylvania and Wisconsin had gone to Hilary Clinton the networks would have called the results in short order. Which goes to show that Trump's allegations of chicanery might not necessarily have been completely wide of the mark. There were postal votes to be counted in Pennsylvania (by hand, apparently, as opposed to electronically in some other states) but that doesn't explain the delay. I gather Trump was making his victory speech when Pennsylvania or Wisconsin came through and brought him over the top. He had clearly got fed up waiting for the networks.

Brexit is restated, confirmed, underlined and strengthened by Donald Trump's victory, and the euro is next. TTIP is for the bin and the future of the EU itself and NATO are now up in the air. It's impossible just now to take it all in or to know where the US and the world will go from here. The US Presidency is a far weaker institution than we think because of the separation of powers, and Donald Trump is as despised by almost as many Republican senators and Congressmen as Clinton, but like Brexit it's the vote that counts. For the second time in just over six months the people have misbehaved and refused to do as they were told. I don't say that the people are always right but they are always sovereign. It will take this victory to bring home to the Remainers in the UK that Brexit means Brexit.

It is no coincidence that the "revolution" bringing about the end of the post WW2 world began in the UK and the US (leaving aside the collapse of the USSR and communism). The UK and the US created the Western dimension of the post war world. They also pushed more than anyone else (with our elite following them without giving it a second thought) for a world of excessive globalization, including in the financial services area. The Big Bang in the UK in 1985 and Larry Summers' disastrous legislation in the US in the 1990s set the scene for the loss of any control of capital movements, which underlie a lot of the problems since. The mad euro experiment of course deserves to be up there also, which is why the euro will be next to feel the wind of change. NAFTA contributed significantly to Trump's victory. I was exchanging tweets at around 6am with a well known economist who felt that globalization had its merits but said that "the corporate interests unchecked fest at society's expense is the problem". Exactly. Where to draw the line between free trade and the rights and responsibilities of governments to govern their territories and protect the interests of their people is the issue: the near total stakeholder capture of Western governments (in this case the US) by global interests is the underlying reason for Donald Trump's victory.

The number crunchers of course were at it all night. More women voted for Donald Trump than were expected to and fewer Latinos voted for Hilary Clinton than we were told was the case. (I'm not surprised in either case. Why would women vote for somebody shady just because she is a woman or Latinos not be able to understand that states must have borders and rules about immigration?) There is no doubt that playing the hyphenated game was a bad tactic for Hilary Clinton. Truth to tell, she might have had no choice but some of her rallies gave the impression of a Tree Huggers for Clinton event. The Democratic Party needs to get away from giving the impression that it is the hyphenated Americans party and get back to being a left of centre party, e.g. ditch NAFTA. (Donald Trump should seek to reverse the increasing balkanization of the US. The most interesting Americans I've ever met have been ... Americans. Hyphenated Americans tend to be less interesting.) It will be interesting to see if the Democrats work that out. I enjoyed the piece by Brian Boyd in Tuesday's Irish Times in which he pointed out that seeking support from rock stars and the like doesn't work. (Speaking of celebrities, where has Bono been? How have we been so lucky!) The article refers to one individual, who, in 2004, particularly resented the fact that Bruce Springsteen, whom the individual correctly described as a song and dance man, urged people to vote for Kerry in that year's Presidential election. I love the Boss and he was right on that occasion but perhaps another consequence of the revolution is that the age of celebrity might be coming to an end. Donald Trump was one but the end of celebrity could be one of the unintended consequences of his victory.

The media has been the stand-out performer in this campaign but for all the wrong reasons. With some fine exceptions, they did everything they could to create the impression that Hilary Clinton was the better candidate and was home and hosed. I don't necessarily blame the polling companies. I can understand how people would be reluctant to say how they intended to vote. No doubt many people kept their heads down at work and among their friends and then quietly voted for Donald Trump. The Clintons' checkered history finally caught up with them. The media did everything they could to down play the pay-for-play strategy of the Clintons but they couldn't bury it. I suspect, however, that the debates ultimately turned the table. I saw part of the first one and all of the second and third ones. Donald Trump improved with every debate while Hilary Clinton failed to get her vision across (although she did to the global elite and the media, who understood that she was their woman). I noticed, particularly after the third debate, that good journalists could not run away from their consciences and started, ever so gingerly, to point out that Donald Trump was developing into something but that Hilary Clinton was standing still. I thought Donald Trump had left it too late to begin to display the necessary political skills but he hadn't. He had to trod a fine line between the angry revolutionary and behaving like a civilized human being. I thought he had got the balance wrong but he obviously hadn't.

The Canadian immigration website crashed during election night. Shades of UK citizens looking for Irish passports after the Brexit referendum. Silly.

It will obviously take some months to see how Donald Trump seeks to turn his victory into significant new policy directions. My first reaction is to breathe a sigh of relief that the world won't be a heap of ashes four years from now. The risk of nuclear war with Russia had Hilary Clinton won would have been very high. Assuming Donald Trump can get the support of the Congress for his measures (which is a huge assumption), if he reduces US corporation tax to 15% that will have a huge impact on the US and global economy. It will oblige this state to move away from Whitaker Economics. I don't underestimate the challenge involved but we have to face the future as well. I hope Donald Trump will instigate a massive renewal of US infrastructure and he should tackle education as well. Hopefully, he will also restructure the Supreme Court and that important social issues like abortion and surrogacy will be addressed. And I hope, he finds a way of keeping the Second Amendment while tackling the US gun culture that has always been a feature of US society but particularly since the end of the US Civil War. Sales of post Civil War surplus weapons gave that culture a boost from which US society has never recovered.

Donald Trump's Cabinet appointments will tell us a lot about his plans for the Presidency. Will he appoint heavy hitters to the economic ministries (and get rid of Janet Yellen, if he can) and lesser figures to State and Defence? Having a businessman in the White House is a huge plus. Will he challenge the military industrial complex, which is consuming (morality aside) far too many resources, resources that the US could spare in the 1950s-1970s but not today? Will he go for the best Cabinet he can and forget the gender balance/must have some gays nonsense?